CJ Affiliate 5898178 claiming commission on organic traffic to 123Inkjets
Co-authored with Ben Edelman
Using a computer running Perion Incredibar adware, our crawler browses the 123Inkjets site. Incredibar sees this traffic and invisibly invokes the CJ click link with publisher ID 5898178, which redirects back to 123Inkjets.
Because the toolbar drops CJ cookies invisibly, there is nothing for us to show in a screenshot. But the network trace confirms what occurred and confirms that the affiliate link was invoked invisibly. Specifically, notice the creation of an invisible IFRAME called tbm_stat (CSS style of display:none, hence invisible). Loaded inside that IFRAME is stat_mn.inc.php which creates another invisible IFRAME called tbmi_stat, again CSS display:none. Within this doubly-invisible IFRAME, the redirect flow sends traffic onwards to the CJ click link — confirming that the cookie-drop occurs completely invisibly.
If a user subsequently makes a purchase, CJ and 123Inkjets records will credit affiliate 5898178 with purportedly causing that purchase. But in fact the user was already at the 123Inkjets site before the Incredibar adware and this affiliate 5898178 intervened. They did nothing to cause or encourage the user’s purchase, and any payments to this affiliate are entirely wasted.
Meanwhile, Incredibar’s advertising fraud is also notable in that Incredibar is made by Perion, a publicly-traded company (NASDAQ: PERI). We see no obvious mechanism whereby Perion could diffuse blame or responsibility to any third party. Investors would no doubt be surprised to learn that Perion’s revenue sources include affiliate fraud.